SUMMER SALE 15% OFF ALL ORDERS OVER $69 taken at checkout

Lubricant Types Explained: How to Choose the Right Lube

by Steve Calenzo

Lubricant is one of the most underrated products in sexual wellness. The right lube reduces friction, increases comfort, and enhances sensation — but the wrong one can damage toys, irritate skin, or compromise condom integrity. Here's what you need to know.

The Four Main Types

Water-Based Lube

Best for: General use, silicone toy compatibility, condom use
Avoid if: You want something that lasts a long time without reapplying

Water-based lubes are the most versatile and universally safe option. They're compatible with all toy materials (including silicone), all condom types, and are easy to clean up. The trade-off: they absorb into skin and dry out faster than other types, so you may need to reapply. Look for formulas without glycerin if you're prone to yeast infections, as glycerin can feed yeast.

Silicone-Based Lube

Best for: Long-lasting sessions, shower/water play, anal use
Avoid if: You're using silicone toys

Silicone lube lasts significantly longer than water-based and doesn't absorb into skin. It's excellent for water play since it doesn't wash away easily. Critical caveat: silicone lube degrades silicone toy surfaces over time, causing them to become sticky and porous. Never use silicone lube with silicone toys. It is safe with latex and polyisoprene condoms.

Oil-Based Lube

Best for: Massage, external use, non-latex condom users
Avoid if: You're using latex condoms or are prone to vaginal infections

Oil-based lubes (including natural options like coconut oil) are long-lasting and great for massage. However, they degrade latex condoms, making them ineffective as a barrier. They can also disrupt vaginal pH and are difficult to clean from fabrics. Use with polyurethane condoms only if barrier protection is needed.

Hybrid Lube

Best for: People who want the longevity of silicone with toy compatibility
Avoid if: You have sensitive skin or are unsure of your toy's material

Hybrid lubes combine water and a small percentage of silicone. They last longer than pure water-based formulas and are generally safe with silicone toys — but always do a patch test on an inconspicuous part of your toy first, as formulations vary.

Specialty Formulas

  • Warming lubes: Contain ingredients like capsaicin or menthol for a warming sensation. Test on your wrist first — some people find them irritating.
  • Cooling/tingling lubes: Similar principle, menthol-based. Great for some, too intense for others.
  • Anal-specific lubes: Typically thicker formulas designed for more cushioning. Often silicone or hybrid-based.
  • Organic/natural lubes: Free from parabens, glycerin, and synthetic additives. A good choice for sensitive skin.

Ingredients to Avoid

  • Glycerin: Can promote yeast growth in vaginal tissue
  • Parabens: Preservatives with potential hormonal effects; many people prefer to avoid them
  • Nonoxynol-9: A spermicide that irritates mucous membranes with repeated use
  • Petroleum-based ingredients: Degrade latex and are difficult to clean

Quick Compatibility Reference

Lube Type Silicone Toys Latex Condoms Water Play
Water-based ✅ Safe ✅ Safe ❌ Washes off
Silicone-based ❌ Avoid ✅ Safe ✅ Great
Oil-based ✅ Safe ❌ Degrades ✅ Good
Hybrid ⚠️ Patch test ✅ Safe ✅ Good

Shop Lubricants

Browse our full Lube collection, including water-based, silicone, and specialty formulas from trusted brands like JO and Wicked.

Back to News